-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi,

How is a letter from a few leaders on the own initiative without any
'democratic' checking with their constituencies, asking for more time
an indication that the whole community indicated no-support.

I for one am satisficed they are moving ahead, we have been waiting to
do this accountability work for years.  Enough talking about it in the
future and time get started with the work.

Yes, they could have introduced it better.
Yes it needs fixing - and they are fixing, hence the call for names,
and the fact that charters will be worked out with the WGs.
Yes, it would have been wise for them to hold yet another comment
period given the extensive model they were offering.

But this desire to argue forever for a perfect mechanism instead of
getting about the work of fixing ICANN accountability continue to
baffle me.

avri

On 29-Aug-14 08:22, Seun Ojedeji wrote:
> Am i missing something? Looks like ICANN is continuing in it's 
> Accountability process irrespective of the communities joint
> letter indicating a no-support.
> 
> Cheers! sent from Google nexus 4 kindly excuse brevity and typos. 
> On 29 Aug 2014 05:04, "Adam" <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> 
>> Accountability & Governance Public Experts Group has published
>> its call for candidates for advisors to the ICANN Accountability
>> & Governance Coordination Group.  Please see < 
>> https://www.icann.org/news/announcement-2014-08-28-en>
>> 
>> text below.
>> 
>> Adam
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> In Short
>> 
>> The Accountability & Governance Public Experts Group is asked to
>> select up to seven advisors to the ICANN Accountability &
>> Governance Coordination Group. As part of executing its mandate,
>> the Public Experts Group is issuing a Call for Candidates to
>> encourage nominations from the community.
>> 
>> Nominations are to be submitted to [log in to unmask] by
>> Wednesday, 10 September 2014 – 23:59 UTC.
>> 
>> Background Information On 14 March 2014 the National
>> Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA)
>> announced its intent to transition its stewardship of the
>> Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) functions to the
>> global multistakeholder community. NTIA asked  the Internet
>> Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), as the IANA
>> functions contractor and global coordinator for the Domain Name
>> System (DNS), to convene a multistakeholder process to develop a
>> proposal for the transition. This process is currently under way
>> as further described here.
>> 
>> During discussions around the transition process, the community
>> raised the broader topic of the impact of the change in the
>> historical contractual relationship with the United States in
>> light of the transition ofNTIA's stewardship role. The community
>> identified the importance of improving ICANN Accountability &
>> Governance as a crucial aspect and, after community consultations
>> at the ICANN 49 and ICANN50 meetings and a comment period on a
>> draft process from 6 May – 27 June 2014, ICANN published afinal
>> Process and Next Steps on 14 August 2014.
>> 
>> Subsequent to this announcement, on 19 August 2014, ICANN
>> announced the formation of the Public Experts Group. These four
>> individuals – who are not part of ICANN's staff or Board – are
>> asked to select up to seven advisors to the Coordination Group.
>> The Public Experts are Mr. Brian Cute, Ms. Jeanette Hofmann, Amb.
>> Janis Karklins, and Hon. Lawrence E. Strickling.
>> 
>> Role of Advisors The role of the Advisors is defined as follows
>> in the Process:
>> 
>> The advisors, selected by the Public Experts Group, will bring
>> an external, independent voice to this process to assure that
>> best practices are brought in from outside of the ICANN
>> community. While there is a level of research and work that the
>> advisors will do on their own, the integration of the advisors
>> with the rest of the Coordination Group is key to considering how
>> the research they perform can be best implemented to solve for
>> the issues identified. The advisors can also help bring inputs
>> in from their own networks as necessary. Utilized correctly, the
>> advisor inputs will not only assist in developing enhanced
>> accountability practices for ICANN, but provide a model that
>> other multistakeholder organizations will strive to meet.
>> 
>> The areas identified for expertise include:
>> 
>> • Internet Technical Operations • International Organizational
>> Reviews • Global Accountability Tools and Metrics • Jurisprudence
>> / Accountability Mechanisms • Internet Consumer Protection
>> (including privacy, human rights and property rights concerns) •
>> Economics (Marketplace and Competition) • Global Ethics
>> Frameworks • Operational, Finance and Process • Board Governance 
>> • Transparency • Risk Management • Governmental Engagement and
>> Relations • Multistakeholder Governance
>> 
>> Selection of Advisors As part of executing its mandate, the
>> Public Experts Group is issuing a Call for Candidates to
>> encourage nominations and self-nomination of suitable candidates.
>> The Public Experts Group may reach out to their networks for
>> additional suggestions.
>> 
>> The Public Experts Group will conduct its activities with a
>> "default open" and its process can be followed, through its
>> mailing list and its Wiki. In evaluating candidates, the Public
>> Expert Group will respect individual candidates' privacy and will
>> deliberate in closed session where appropriate.
>> 
>> How to Submit a Nomination The Public Experts Group is seeking
>> nominations for individuals to serve as Advisors to the
>> Coordination Group. Nominations should include the following:
>> 
>> • A brief description of the candidate's background • Identified
>> area(s) of expertise based on the list in the Process.
>> 
>> Nominations should be emailed to [log in to unmask] Upon
>> receipt of a nomination, ICANN staff will confirm with the
>> candidate if he/she is indeed willing to be considered.
>> 
>> Deadline Nominations will be accepted until Wednesday, 10
>> September – 23:59 UTC. The Public Experts Group will select
>> Advisors to the Coordination Group in time for the first
>> Coordination Group meeting, which will take place from during the
>> ICANN 51 meeting in Los Angeles from 12-16 October 2014.
>> 
>> Timeline Advisors are anticipated to serve on the Coordination
>> Group from October 2014 until April 2015. During this time,
>> Advisors can estimate 5-10h of work per week, with a heightened
>> workload during the ICANN51 (12 – 16 October 2014) and ICANN 52
>> (8 – 12 February 2015) meetings where travel for in person
>> meetings is expected.
>> 
>> NB: The timeline described above is the Public Experts Group's
>> assessment based on the Process and is subject to change after
>> the Coordination Group determines its working methods.
>> 
>> Compensation Advisors will not receive remuneration for their
>> time. However, travel, meal and lodging costs to participate in
>> Coordination Group meetings will be reimbursed upon request in
>> accordance withICANN's community travel support guidelines.
>> 
>> Contact Please contact [log in to unmask] for any questions
>> you may have.
>> 
> 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (MingW32)

iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJUAEFfAAoJEOo+L8tCe36HSL4H/iZeCeD9l1t/qe636ODPsLWj
fE/r2+rxI5sF4u4TcSwZG531CGZp8oHnD6oh9qDlROyW5JFzEmZClkkO1DiBKKL1
6ees1eJg5vvrxUtd+4UEA3UPDkx9i05tVC8jns+43ejxgXtrbSHJ4jyS+IQIMwjD
svs+WjG4pqZ+M8URop/1r72T7jbLJHXtKcBR9NIBHHQ8SvuusdTTJbmL3/FNKuxc
1BstBlrBDoyaLfs1NfOW/AJBmDTf0s9/rVQLhW9C/OjLA+/tFApsCJnUWXWuGP6Y
khgmg4CQY7D5Gu2Rq0UJAS1HCcLnl/9MFCSFoHJ3U0po6S4Bs7laHXuxVPyJGKg=
=oGX3
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----