The simple idea that someone has something to hide gives me the creeps.... BR, Nuno 2010/1/28 David Cake <[log in to unmask]>: > At 5:09 PM -0800 27/1/10, Robin Gross wrote: >> >> I'm not so keen on the amendment re: Chatham House rule. I don't like >> the idea that the review teams can decide its a secret and its a secret. >> Its too easy and there is no limitation on what they can decide is an >> exceptional circumstance. > > The Chatham house rule means that nothing that is said is secret, > only who said it. If, in some peoples discomfort with the Chatham house > rule, we end up giving review teams the option to use more restrictive > rules, that would be a poor outcome. > Cheers > David >